glenn schrooyenandClaude Opus 5
2bb07ccdde
checks / unit (pull_request) Successful in 6m9s
Applying review finding N1, which was non-blocking because it fails closed, and
N2, which is a fabricated number.
N1. Clearing the `max_w` box answered HTTP 500 on a non-JSON body, which the
page rendered as "cannot reach the add-on" - untrue, and for the most prominent
limit field's most likely transient state. The cause was a disagreement between
two files that `inverter.py`'s own docstring says to keep in step:
validate.py `_number()` reads "" as "use the default", so rule 9 saw 2000
and was content
inverter.py line 515 did a bare `float(opts.get("max_w", 2000))`, which
raises ValueError on ""
So a shape rule 9 TOLERATED could not be composed at all - the docstring's rule
inverted. The roster path never had this: `_entry_max_w` already guards. Only
the flat single-inverter path did. `_flat_max_w()` now reads empty as the
default exactly as `_number()` does, and unparseable as 0.0 exactly as
`_entry_max_w` does, where rule 9 refuses it by name at line 790.
⚠️ THE FIRST ATTEMPT AT THIS MADE IT WORSE, AND THE PROBE CAUGHT IT. Guarding
`build_roster` in `selfconfig` with `except: return validate(opts), []` turned
the 500 into ZERO PROBLEMS for `max_w: ""` - the validator has nothing to say
about it, so an empty list came back and the page would have ENABLED SAVE. A
crash became a silent acceptance. The guard is kept as a backstop for shapes
neither file anticipates, but it can no longer return an empty list: if the
roster cannot be composed and the validator names no reason, that disagreement
is itself reported.
MEASURED after the fix, `problems_and_ranges` with no HA:
max_w 5000, slew_w 400 0 problems (the live shape)
max_w "", slew_w 400 1 problem rule 10, "against a site rail of
2000 W" - clearing the box FAILS
CLOSED on the live install rather
than silently halving the rail
max_w "", slew_w 0 0 problems accepted at the 2000 default
max_w "abc" 1 problem "max_w 'abc' is not a number"
Before the fix, both "" and "abc" raised ValueError instead.
N2. `translations/en.yaml:7` said "all 71 keys ... so ALL SEVENTY are rendered".
The 70->71 correction had been made in one half of the sentence and not the
other. 59-of-71 required is correct and was re-measured.
Suite: 24 files, all pass.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01BwRLw7eKYj2byVdwB6kbjU