UX-01: translate the add-on config, and order it by task
checks / unit (pull_request) Successful in 5m1s
checks / unit (pull_request) Successful in 5m1s
The add-on had NO translations/ directory, so Home Assistant fell back to rendering the raw option KEYS. An operator opening Configuration read `unit_sign_disagree_w`, `saturation_cycles`, `integrator_max_w` - seventy of them, in file order, with no description and no way to tell a constant derived from 1890 closed-loop test runs from their own inverter's rating. ⚠️ PRESENTATION ONLY. Not one default, not one schema range and not one line of behaviour moved. The 175 non-comment lines of config.yaml are byte-identical to release/1.0's, reordered; the only comment lines that changed are the group banners and five sentences whose "above"/"below" the reorder made false. * translations/en.yaml and translations/nl.yaml: a name and a description for all 70 options and all 7 per-entry keys of the `inverters:` repeatable section. The Dutch is written for a Flemish homeowner - afname/injectie, kwartierpiek, capaciteitstarief - not transliterated from the English. * ⭐ Every derived constant says WHERE IT CAME FROM and whether to touch it. `unit_sign_disagree_s` cites its 1890 closed-loop runs (SAFETY-30); `circulation_w` its 924 runs and the measured 400 W knee (SAFETY-31); `meter_freeze_s` its 2399 s capture (SAFETY-18); `bms_soc_floor` register 0x0560. The two numbers that are the operator's - max_w and peak_cap_w - say "THIS IS YOUR NUMBER". `cycle_cost_threshold_eur`, which is neither, says it is an open product question (OPT-08). * config.yaml reordered into task order in BOTH halves, comments carried with their keys: hardware -> meter -> ratings and limits -> tariff -> maintenance -> safety -> advanced. ⚠️ test_inverter.py:1788's trap is PRESERVED: the nested per-entry `max_w:` still precedes the flat one under `schema:`, and `inverters: []` still ships in the `options:` half. Moving the nested block below the flat one is a 1-byte edit; it was run and goes red in test_inverter.py and test_translations.py. * tools/supervisor_shape_probe.py section F MEASURES the result against ghcr.io/home-assistant/amd64-hassio-supervisor:2026.08.0 - Supervisor's own _read_app_translations(), its own UiOptions, and the frontend's label resolution transcribed from the shipped bundle - and prints every rendered row in both languages. `all cases passed`, exit 0. * ⚠️ ONE MEASURED NEGATIVE RESULT, NOT GLOSSED: the per-entry keys inside the `inverters:` section still render RAW on frontend 20250925.1, because a list-of-objects goes to ha-selector-object and the converter sets no `label` and no `translation_key`. The `fields:` translations are shipped and validated - that is Supervisor's own shape for this - but this card does not claim they reach the screen. The `inverters` label and description do. * test_translations.py: a translation naming a non-existent option, or an option with no translation, fails CI - both directions, both languages, top level and per entry. Mutation-tested BOTH WAYS: eleven in-process mutations each required to NAME the key they broke, plus a negative control; six more run on disk through the purge-and-re-read protocol. Two of the eleven are the ones that cost the WHOLE FILE rather than one label - an unrecognised top-level block, and a `network:` value that is not a string. Supervisor drops a file that fails SCHEMA_APP_TRANSLATIONS with only a log warning, so those silently return the entire tab to raw keys; neither is reachable through the `configuration:` coverage, which is why they were hunted for and closed. * tools/translations_lint.py is the hand parser CI needs (no PyYAML in the add-on image) and the probe grades it, key by key and string by string, against Supervisor's own loader. It is strict and RAISES rather than skipping; nine malformed shapes prove it. Full 20-file suite green (19 existing + test_translations.py). Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com> Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01BwRLw7eKYj2byVdwB6kbjU
This commit is contained in:
@@ -272,6 +272,180 @@ except Exception as e: # noqa: BLE001
|
||||
show("Supervisor's UI renderer survives the shape", False, f"{type(e).__name__}: {e}")
|
||||
|
||||
|
||||
print("\n== F. UX-01: the TRANSLATED Configuration tab, rendered ==")
|
||||
# ⚠️ WHAT THIS SECTION MEASURES, AND WHY IT IS NOT AN ASSERTION ABOUT A FILE.
|
||||
# UX-01 adds translations/en.yaml and translations/nl.yaml. Whether they reach
|
||||
# an operator depends on two pieces of somebody else's software, not on us:
|
||||
#
|
||||
# 1. SUPERVISOR decides whether a file is loaded at all.
|
||||
# `supervisor/store/data.py:_read_app_translations()` globs this directory,
|
||||
# keys each file by its STEM, and runs it through `SCHEMA_APP_TRANSLATIONS`.
|
||||
# ⚠️ A FILE THAT FAILS THAT SCHEMA IS DROPPED WITH A LOG WARNING AND
|
||||
# NOTHING ELSE: `except (ConfigurationFileError, vol.Invalid): _LOGGER.
|
||||
# warning(...); continue`. The add-on then renders raw keys and the only
|
||||
# trace is one line in the Supervisor log. So the loader is RUN here, out
|
||||
# of the release image, rather than the schema being re-implemented.
|
||||
# 2. THE FRONTEND decides what it does with what Supervisor loaded. The
|
||||
# resolution below is not invented: it is transcribed from the shipped
|
||||
# bundle in THIS image, `api/panel/frontend_latest/5680.*.js`
|
||||
# (frontend 20250925.1), which reads
|
||||
#
|
||||
# _getTranslationEntry(lang,s,o){let e=this.addon.translations[lang]?.
|
||||
# configuration; if(e){if(o?.path)for(const t of o.path)
|
||||
# if(e=e[t]?.fields,!e)return; return e[s.name]}}
|
||||
# computeLabel =(s,_,o)=>this._getTranslationEntry(this.hass.language,s,o)?.name
|
||||
# ||this._getTranslationEntry("en",s,o)?.name||s.name
|
||||
# computeHelper=(s,o) =>this._getTranslationEntry(this.hass.language,s,o)?.description
|
||||
# ||this._getTranslationEntry("en",s,o)?.description||""
|
||||
# _filteredSchema=(opts,schema)=>schema.filter(e=>e.name in opts||e.required)
|
||||
#
|
||||
# i.e. the fallback is PER KEY, en is the second chance, and the raw key
|
||||
# name is the third.
|
||||
from supervisor.apps.validate import SCHEMA_APP_TRANSLATIONS # noqa: E402
|
||||
from supervisor.store.data import _read_app_translations # noqa: E402
|
||||
|
||||
TRANSLATIONS = _read_app_translations(Path("/w"))
|
||||
show("Supervisor's OWN translation loader accepts both files - a file that "
|
||||
"fails SCHEMA_APP_TRANSLATIONS is DROPPED with a log warning and the tab "
|
||||
"silently goes back to raw keys, so 'it is on disk' is not the question",
|
||||
set(TRANSLATIONS) == {"en", "nl"}, sorted(TRANSLATIONS))
|
||||
|
||||
ui = UiOptions(None)(schema)
|
||||
print(f" the Configuration tab renders {len(ui)} fields, in `schema:` order "
|
||||
"(App.schema_ui is UiOptions(...)(data['schema']), so the ORDER IS THE "
|
||||
"SCHEMA BLOCK'S and not the options block's)")
|
||||
|
||||
|
||||
def _entry(lang, name, path=()):
|
||||
node = TRANSLATIONS.get(lang, {}).get("configuration")
|
||||
if not node:
|
||||
return None
|
||||
for step in path:
|
||||
node = (node.get(step) or {}).get("fields")
|
||||
if not node:
|
||||
return None
|
||||
return node.get(name)
|
||||
|
||||
|
||||
def _label(lang, name, path=()):
|
||||
for lg in (lang, "en"):
|
||||
e = _entry(lg, name, path)
|
||||
if e and e.get("name"):
|
||||
return e["name"], lg
|
||||
return name, "RAW KEY"
|
||||
|
||||
|
||||
def _helper(lang, name, path=()):
|
||||
for lg in (lang, "en"):
|
||||
e = _entry(lg, name, path)
|
||||
if e and e.get("description"):
|
||||
return e["description"], lg
|
||||
return "", "NONE"
|
||||
|
||||
|
||||
# ⚠️ EVERY FIELD, PRINTED. This is the transcript the card asks for: what the
|
||||
# owner's Supervisor puts on the screen, not a claim that it would look nice.
|
||||
for lang in ("en", "nl"):
|
||||
print(f"\n --- as rendered at hass.language == {lang!r} "
|
||||
f"(the owner's HA runs Europe/Brussels) ---")
|
||||
for node in ui:
|
||||
lbl, src = _label(lang, node["name"])
|
||||
hlp, hsrc = _helper(lang, node["name"])
|
||||
flag = "" if src == lang else f" [name from {src}]"
|
||||
print(f" {node['name']:28s} -> {lbl}{flag}")
|
||||
print(f" {'':28s} {hlp[:150]}{'...' if len(hlp) > 150 else ''}")
|
||||
for sub in node.get("schema", ()):
|
||||
slbl, ssrc = _label(lang, sub["name"], (node["name"],))
|
||||
print(f" · {sub['name']:24s} -> {slbl}"
|
||||
+ ("" if ssrc == lang else f" [{ssrc}]"))
|
||||
|
||||
_raw = [n["name"] for n in ui if _label("en", n["name"])[1] == "RAW KEY"]
|
||||
show("NOT ONE top-level field falls through to its raw key name in `en` - "
|
||||
f"which is what the tab rendered for all {len(ui)} of them before this "
|
||||
f"card, because there was no translations/ directory at all. Raw: {_raw}",
|
||||
not _raw)
|
||||
_nohelp = [n["name"] for n in ui if not _helper("en", n["name"])[0]]
|
||||
show("...and not one is left without a description, which is the half that "
|
||||
f"says WHETHER TO TOUCH IT. Missing: {_nohelp}", not _nohelp)
|
||||
_nl_missing = [n["name"] for n in ui if _label("nl", n["name"])[1] != "nl"]
|
||||
show("...and every one of them is translated in `nl` too, so nothing on the "
|
||||
f"owner's own screen falls back to English. Falling back: {_nl_missing}",
|
||||
not _nl_missing)
|
||||
|
||||
# ⚠️ THE HONEST HALF, AND IT IS A NEGATIVE RESULT. `inverters` is a
|
||||
# list-of-objects, so UiOptions gives it type "schema" WITH multiple: True, and
|
||||
# `_convertSchemaElement` sends exactly that case to a SELECTOR rather than to a
|
||||
# nested ha-form:
|
||||
#
|
||||
# if("schema"===t.type&&!t.multiple) return {...type:"expandable"...} <- not us
|
||||
# if("schema"===t.type){const o={};for(const a of t.schema)
|
||||
# o[a.name]={required:a.required,selector:...}; return {object:{multiple:t.multiple,fields:o}}}
|
||||
#
|
||||
# and ha-selector-object labels those fields with
|
||||
#
|
||||
# computeLabel=e=>{const t=this.selector.object?.translation_key;
|
||||
# if(this.localizeValue&&t){...}
|
||||
# return this.selector.object?.fields?.[e.name]?.label||e.name}
|
||||
#
|
||||
# `_convertSchemaElementToSelector` sets neither `label` nor `translation_key`,
|
||||
# so ON THIS FRONTEND the per-entry keys inside the repeatable section render as
|
||||
# `setpoint_entity`, `max_w`, `bms_soc_floor` - RAW - however well they are
|
||||
# translated here. The `fields:` block is still shipped and still validated,
|
||||
# because it is the shape Supervisor's own schema defines for exactly this and
|
||||
# it is what a frontend that wires `label` through would consume; but this card
|
||||
# must not claim it reaches the operator today, and the count below is asserted
|
||||
# so that the day it changes, this transcript says so.
|
||||
_multi = [n for n in ui if n.get("multiple") and n.get("type") == "schema"]
|
||||
show("`inverters` is rendered as a REPEATABLE SECTION (type schema, multiple), "
|
||||
"which is CFG-04's measurement re-confirmed",
|
||||
[n["name"] for n in _multi] == ["inverters"], json.dumps(_multi)[:200])
|
||||
show("⚠️ MEASURED AND NEGATIVE: this frontend gives that section's per-entry "
|
||||
"keys to ha-selector-object, which labels them `fields[name].label || "
|
||||
"name` - and the converter sets no `label` and no `translation_key`. So "
|
||||
"the per-entry translations below are SHIPPED AND VALIDATED but do NOT "
|
||||
"reach the screen on 20250925.1. The top-level `inverters` label and "
|
||||
"description DO.",
|
||||
bool(_multi) and all("label" not in s and "translation_key" not in s
|
||||
for n in _multi for s in n.get("schema", ())),
|
||||
"per-entry keys as rendered today: "
|
||||
+ ", ".join(s["name"] for n in _multi for s in n.get("schema", ())))
|
||||
|
||||
# ⚠️ AND THE HAND PARSER CI USES IS GRADED AGAINST THIS LOADER, KEY BY KEY.
|
||||
# test_translations.py runs in the add-on's CI image, which has no PyYAML, so it
|
||||
# parses these files with tools/translations_lint.py. A hand parser that
|
||||
# disagrees with the real loader is a check whose data cannot reach the failure
|
||||
# it names, so the two are compared here - where both are available - rather
|
||||
# than assumed to agree.
|
||||
sys.path.insert(0, "/probe")
|
||||
import translations_lint as _tl # noqa: E402
|
||||
_mismatch = []
|
||||
for lang in ("en", "nl"):
|
||||
hand = _tl.parse_translation_file(f"/w/translations/{lang}.yaml")
|
||||
real = {"configuration": TRANSLATIONS[lang].get("configuration", {})}
|
||||
# SCHEMA_APP_TRANSLATIONS fills `description: None` for an absent one; the
|
||||
# hand parser simply has no key. Normalise that ONE difference and nothing
|
||||
# else, so a real disagreement cannot hide behind the normalisation.
|
||||
def _norm(d):
|
||||
return {k: {kk: vv for kk, vv in v.items() if vv is not None
|
||||
and kk != "fields"}
|
||||
| ({"fields": _norm(v["fields"])} if v.get("fields") else {})
|
||||
for k, v in d.items()}
|
||||
if _norm(hand.get("configuration", {})) != _norm(real["configuration"]):
|
||||
a, b = _norm(hand.get("configuration", {})), _norm(real["configuration"])
|
||||
_mismatch += [f"{lang}:{k}" for k in sorted(set(a) | set(b))
|
||||
if a.get(k) != b.get(k)]
|
||||
show("the hand parser CI uses (tools/translations_lint.py) returns EXACTLY "
|
||||
"what Supervisor's own loader returns, for both files, key by key and "
|
||||
f"string by string. Disagreements: {_mismatch}", not _mismatch)
|
||||
_cfg_text = Path("/w/config.yaml").read_text(encoding="utf-8")
|
||||
_probs = []
|
||||
for lang in ("en", "nl"):
|
||||
_probs += _tl.audit(
|
||||
_cfg_text,
|
||||
{"configuration": TRANSLATIONS[lang].get("configuration", {})}, lang)
|
||||
show(f"...and the coverage audit is clean against the real loader's view too. "
|
||||
f"Problems: {_probs}", not _probs)
|
||||
|
||||
# ⚠️ THE EXIT CODE IS PART OF THE INSTRUMENT. Without it the probe prints FAIL
|
||||
# and still succeeds, and a transcript is only evidence if a wrong answer is
|
||||
# distinguishable from a right one by something other than reading it.
|
||||
|
||||
Reference in New Issue
Block a user